Journal Entry

Ok remember what we are hunting for cosmic rays. For more on cosmic rays click here. But the short story is that cosmic rays are basically charged particles from outer space. Specifically we are interested in stuff coming from the Sun so we can better understand solar activity. For why we should care click here.
The problem is that most cosmic rays from the sun don't make it all the way to the ground. Imagine a proton blasted off the surface of the sun that hurtles toward the Earth. Well pretty quick upon entering the atmosphere that proton is going to interact with an atom in the atmosphere so it doesn't make it all the way to the ground. But don't loose hope. When the proton (or other cosmic ray) blasts into the atom it can produce other particles. One of those particles is a neutron.

Air ShowerDiagram at the CosRay Building of a cosmic ray producing other particles called an air shower.

But detecting neutrons can be tricky. They don't have an electrical charge. Detecting charged particles is easy. You can fill a tube with a gas, stick a charged wire in it, and ground the outside. Any charged particle entering the gas will want to go either to the charge or the ground. That creates a current which you can measure. That's basically how a Geiger Counter works. Anyway, we can't do that with neutrons. But there is an isotope of Boron that is really good at absorbing neutrons. It's called Boron 10. Anyway, when Boron 10 absorbs a neutron it breaks up. Specifically, it breaks up into Lithium 7 and Helium. Those are charged and they will also have enough energy to ionize some stuff around it creating even more charge (which is easy to detect.)
So the guts of the neutron monitor is a tube of a gas called Boron Trifluride (enriched so that most of the Boron is Boron 10). And there is a voltage across the tube so when that neutron comes along and makes the Boron break up then... wham! You have detected a neutron. But wait. There is another problem. There are neutrons around us all the time so you can't just leave the tube sitting on a table. You have to make sure only the neutrons we want get into the tube. The neutrons produced by cosmic rays are very high energy. The ones around us are low energy. So we screen the low energy ones out. Polyethylene will work for that. Low energy neutrons won't make it though that stuff but high energy ones will. But the high energy ones will probably also make it through the tube of gas. So we need a layer of polyethylene to block low energy neutrons but then we need some lead to absorb the high energy ones. The lead absorbs the high energy ones and becomes radioactive. It immediately gives off 8-12 low energy neutrons. THOSE neutrons hit the Boron 10 and cause it to break up into stuff that is easy to detect.

Neutron Monitor The white plastic (polyethylene) screens out ordinary neutrons. The grey metal (lead) grabs the neutron and gives off more which the Boron in the tube then does its thing with.

Whew! Thats a lot but here's the basics. Cosmic ray hits the atmosphere and frees up a high energy neutron. The high energy neutron makes it to our detector and makes it through the polyethylene that keeps out regular neutrons. But then it gets to the lead and is absorbed. The lead gives off low energy neutrons which interact with the Boron which produces charged, easy to detect stuff.

Neutron Monitor diagramCosmic ray hits stuff, make neutrons -> neutron makes it past polyethelyene into lead -> lead uses neutron to make more -> neutrons get absorbed by boron which fissions into detectable stuff

Comments

Sebi kulyckyj

Why do you need to detect the neutrons, why do the neutrons concern us?

Trudi Dunning

When you say that most of the neutrons don't make it to the ground, what percentage make it into our atmosphere, and what percentage are lost on their way through the atmosphere to the ground?
Still have Neutron Dance in my head.

Eric Thuma

The neutrons are produced when cosmic rays from the sun hit the atmosphere. So we can use it to study the sun and the effects of solar storms on Earth

Eric Thuma

It's actually the initial cosmic ray that doesn't make it to the ground. When the cosmic ray enters the atmosphere it will typically collide with an atom in the air and produce neutrons which do make it. Some cosmic rays do make it though but the exact percent that makes it through is a complicated question. It depends on the nature and energy of the cosmic ray as well as the altitude of the detector.

Matthew D'Onofrio

Even though it's easy to record, how exactly are you guys detecting the products of neutrons hitting Boron 10?

Eric Thuma

Excellent question. They put a big voltage across the gas. But usually current can't flow through the gas. But when the Boron breaks up, it is very energetic and ionizes the gas. Then it acts as a conductor and current flows and that current can be measured. That's basically how a geiger counter works.

Josh Cowdrey

Are you gonna grow like a third eye or something from working with all this radioactive lead? And how are the penguins?

Griffin Green

Where do the cosmic rays that don't make it all the way to the ground go? Also, what is so special about Boron 10 that it can absorb neutrons and break them up into Lithium 7 and Helium?

Griffin Green

Where do the cosmic rays that don't make it all the way to the ground go? Also, what is so special about Boron 10 that it can absorb neutrons and break them up into Lithium 7 and Helium?

Ryan Garman

It always boggles my mind how this kind of stuff is going on all of the time without us noticing. So when a proton hits an atom in the upper atmosphere and a neutron breaks off, is that neutron still traveling close to the speed of light? Should we be worried about these fast moving neutrons effecting humans? Also how good is the atmosphere at slowing down these particles? I'm guessing that they would slow down at least a little bit in the lower atmosphere, kinda like light does.

Eric Thuma

Nope. Only the atom that absorbs the neutron is radioactive. So there aren't that many free neutrons being created. Also remember the lead is inside the polyethelyne so the low energy neutrons are trapped in there.

Eric Thuma

If a cosmic ray doesn't make it to the ground then it is because it has interacted with something in the atmosphere... been absorbed, given up some of its energy, or been changed, or something like that.

Eric Thuma

Boron Boron 10 is special because it is easy for neutrons to interact with. Physicists like to say that it has a large cross section meaning there is a large area in which Boron 10 will interact with a neutron.

Eric Thuma

I wouldn't worry. The atmosphere does provide some shielding from cosmic radiation. Michigan isn't very high in elevation so that shielding is large. The magnetic field provides a lot of protection too, even before things get to the atmosphere. But we are evolved to live on this planet the background radiation in most places is very small.

Angelina Napoleone

We had a snow day today because of a high wind watch and a winter weather alert. How does that make you feelYou went to the bottom of the earth and are actually experiencing the same, if not better weather than up here.

Doug Hill

... from back at LME?
If so, I hope you are well. Glad to see you're connected with Mr. Thuma. He's an outstanding teacher (plus he's really, really smart!).

Add new comment