Journal Entry

Meeting Up with Fellow PolarTREC Teachers

So far, one of the best things about PolarTREC has been meeting some amazing teachers. Each of us will be going our separate ways on our individual expeditions, but we will continue sharing and communicating with each other in order to partake in the science and become better teachers. I would like to introduce two of my friends/fellow teachers and hope that you might be interested in following their expeditions as well.

Sian Proctor

Sian is a geology professor at South Mountain Community College in Phoenix, Arizona. She surprised me at dinner one night when she mentioned that she lived for four months in a dome on the northern slope of Mauna Loa as part of a NASA project simulating a long duration Mars mission. OK, that's not something most teachers do. Sian will travel to Barrow, Alaska to study historical ecology at about the same time that I am in Svalbard. You can follow her expedition here: Historical Ecology of Risk Management

Dominique Richardson

Dominique is a science educator at the Cabrillo Marine Aquarium. A year from now, Dominique will join the crew of the Research Vessel Nathaniel B. Palmer to study the vulnerability of the East Antarctic ice sheet. Dominique has done all kinds of cool things studying ecology and animal behavior including research in Africa and underwater observations of whales. You can follow her expedition here: Antarctic Ice Stream Dynamics

The Cabrillo Marine Aquarium

.be We met on a very rainy day at the Cabrillo Marine Aquarium in San Pedro, California. I drove up from San Diego, Sian was in Los Angeles for a conference and Dominique was our host.

Cool Things I Learned That I Didn't Know Before

I learned some really cool things. In fact, I was asking myself, "How did I get this far through life without knowing this before?" Some of you might think, "Hey ya, didn't you study oceanography in college?" So first a disclaimer. Oceanography is not marine biology. In college, I learned nothing about fish. Instead, I was slogging through problems like, "Derive an equation that describes a wave that forms at the boundary between two water masses of different temperatures" and wondering why I would ever need this skill. (I have not used it to this day.) So you never know when life will throw you for a a loop and you will say, "Wow! I never knew that!"

Cool Thing #1

So I never knew that sharks hatch from weird looking rectangular shaped egg sacks that kind of look like leaves but are actually hard and rubbery, Quite frankly, I've never given any thought to how sharks are born. Apparently sharks are born in a variety of ways; some are live born while others hatch from eggs. At the aquarium they had swellshark egg sacks and babies. These sharks spend 13 months inside their egg sacks! The egg sacks are attached to reefs and are camouflaged among the kelp. In the video you can see one of the babies inside the egg. You can see the embyro attached to the yolk; it looks like it is fighting to get out of there! As adults, swellsharks can grow up to three feet long.

Cool Thing #2

In the video you might have noticed this fish:

A Sheephead Wrasse at the Cabrillo Marine AquariumA Sheephead Wrasse at the Cabrillo Marine Aquarium

Pretty little fish; it is a Sheephead Wrasse. She (and it is a she) is sporting a nice feminine pink color. But not for long, because the Sheephead Wrasse is a sequential hermaphrodite. Oh yeah, she's going to change herself into a guy. Well, actually she might. The transformation is triggered by the removal of alpha males. So they make the change when necessary as cued by the social environment. By the way clownfish (think Nemo) are also sequential hermaphrodites, potentially making the movie a little weird.

Cool Thing #3

Look at the weird eyes on that flounder!  Photo courtesy of Maui Ocean Center.Look at the weird eyes on that flounder! Photo courtesy of Maui Ocean Center.

OK, so there is a group of fish known as flatfish, the most well known perhaps is flounder. Flatfish camouflage themselves by lying on the bottom of the ocean floor. I just always assumed that these fish had body plans like rays with eyes on the top and mouths underneath. Well, maybe not assumed; again I have never given it much thought. But no- in the larval stage flatfish swim like a normal fish and have an eye on each side of their body. As they transition to the juvenile stage, one eye migrates to the other side of the body, actually passing through the brain. As an adult, when the flatfish lies flat on the bottom, it lies so both eyes are up, but the mouth is still stuck on one side. As a result, there are right sided and left sided flatfish depending on which side of the mouth the eyes migrate to. The frequency of left sided fish is much less and approximates the same frequency as left handed humans. Isn't that weird?

You never know when life will throw you for a loop and you will say, "Wow! I never knew that!"

Comments

Guest

This is Nicole and Sarah from period 6. Why do swellsharks spend 13 months inside it's egg sack?

Peggy McNeal

Hi Sarah and Nicole,It is their gestational period during which time they develop as an embryo. They aren't ready to be born yet. Just like human babies spend nine months before a live birth, the swellshark spends 13 months inside the egg sack. That is a long time!

Peggy McNeal

Kendra and Antonio,No, it still needs another fish of the opposite sex :)

Peggy McNeal

Kamryn and Hunter,The environment that a particular shark species has adapted to determines whether it has evolved to lay egg sacs or have live births. So things like the abundance of predators or the vegetation present to camouflage in would influence these adaptations. To be clear…within a species they cannot choose to do either. A single species will either lay egg sacs or give birth live.

Peggy McNeal

Joseph,Well apparently not. Those fish I saw were very much alive. The fish has adaptations that allow it to do this.

Peggy McNeal

Jessica and Andrew,I don't know specifics, but it is a type of metamorphosis because prior to the eye migration the fish is in the larval stage and after it is an adult. Think of the remarkable change a caterpillar goes through on becoming a butterfly and I think that will help you imagine that this transition is similar.

Peggy McNeal

Cameron and Kaitlyn,Great question! I don't know specifics, but it is a type of metamorphosis because prior to the eye migration the fish is in the larval stage and after it is an adult. Think of the remarkable change a caterpillar goes through on becoming a butterfly and I think that will help you imagine that this transition is similar.

Guest

Allyssa Gardner and Ramiro Quesada - Period: 4
How does the adaptaion (the eye moving to one side) help them survive?

Guest

This is Brandon from period 6, why do the Sheephead wrasse change from a female to a male?

Guest

Why is the shark in its egg for so long.?

Guest

This is Delaney and Jessica from period 6.
When the fish changes to a male, does her color change too? Also, does she grow new male parts?

Guest

how does the eye travel through the brain

Guest

This is Brady DeHaven and Jake Coker from period 6
How would it change itself, and could it mate with both males and females?

Guest

Jackie Battle and Luis Almeida's question: Why are some sharks live born and some hatched from eggs?

Guest

how long does the process of the change take

Guest

How deep in the ocean does they fish need to live to be able to surive? danny estrada and aliya bram period 6

Peggy McNeal

Danny and Aliya,What a great question! Different species of fish have evolved to survive in different depths of the ocean. Amazingly, life is found in all depths. Most fish live in the photic zone, where they make use of light energy, but organisms have been found living even in the ocean's greatest depths. The fish of the deep-sea are among the strangest and most elusive creatures on Earth. Since there is no sunlight, most are blind and rely on other senses to interpret their environment. Some have developed the ability to create their own light (bioluminescence) and super large eyes to gather as much light as possible. Life is amazing!

Peggy McNeal

how long does the process of the change take
I assume you are asking about the eye migration of flat fish? I don't really know, but I'm thinking about a month. Maybe you can find out!

Peggy McNeal

The environment that a particular shark species has adapted to determines whether it has evolved to lay egg sacs or have live births. So things like the abundance of predators or the vegetation present to camouflage in would influence these adaptations.

Peggy McNeal

Brady and Jake,The wrasse's unique anatomy, regulated by hormonal changes as triggered by social cues cause the change. Weird, huh? Normal mating occurs after that, between males and females.

Peggy McNeal

Trevor and Tia,it is a type of metamorphosis because prior to the eye migration the fish is in the larval stage and after it is an adult. Think of the remarkable change a caterpillar goes through on becoming a butterfly and I think that will help you imagine that this transition is similar.

Peggy McNeal

Delaney and Jessica,Yes to both! The two sexes have extremely different appearances.

Peggy McNeal

Taylor,That is the gestational period (how much time it takes the fetus to grow prior to birth). Different animals are born after different lengths of gestation (pregnancy or time in egg). For example, for cats it's a few months and for elephants it's over a year and a half.

Peggy McNeal

Brandon,Not sure; there are a few hypotheses explaining potential causes for hermaphroditism. One is that it increases genetic variability. In other words, spreads out the gene pool and limits inbreeding which is an evolutionary advantage.

Peggy McNeal

Oh, great question! Because with their eyes on one side they can now lay flat on the floor of the ocean and still see because both eyes are up. Why would they want to lay fly on the floor of the ocean? To escape predators. Over time, they will become the same color as the ocean floor and are camouflaged. That is really cool.

Guest

I didnt know any of this fish stuff! I have never heard of the switching genders thing, That is crazy

Peggy McNeal

Yes, crazy isn't it?  It gives meaning to "you learn something new everyday".  Keep learning!

Guest

Lauren & Henry, period 2

How come they have antlers if they don't fight?

Guest

Brooke Johnson and Brooke Riddle- Period 4
How does the fish decide if the eye goes on the right side or the left side?

Peggy McNeal

It doesn't!  The eye just moves on its own.  It's like asking you "How did you decide to be right handed or left handed?"  Well, you didn't decide…you just are.  In fact they refer to the fish as right-eyed or left-eyed and studies show that left-eyed fish occur at about the same rate as left handed-people.  Isn't that funny?

Guest

this is Jaden mack from 1st period and why does the that fishes eye move from on side to another

Peggy McNeal

Lauren and Henry,Great question!  It's kind of like asking "Why do you have an appendix if you don't even need one?"The reindeer have adapted to their new environment  and undergone some evolutionary and behavioral changes.  But they are still reindeer and haven't completely evolved into different species.  Therefore they  still have the same basic body plan as the rest of the reindeer species.

Peggy McNeal

Jaden,
1st period? OK.
It goes through a metamorphosis, like a caterpillar to a butterfly. Once the eye migration is complete, it can lay flat on the ocean floor and be camouflaged. With both eyes on the side that is up it can still see! How cool is that?

Guest

This is Jessica and Andrew from period 4. How does the eye pass through the brain?

Guest

Joseph M
per 4

Wouldn't when the fishes eyes go through its brain it would die

Guest

This is Cameron and Kaitlyn from per. 4. We were wondering how the flatfish's brain accommodates the eye moving through?

Guest

this is kamryn and hunter from period 6, what determines whether a shark gives live birth or is hatched from an egg?

Guest

This is Kendra Rollins and Antonio Olivieri from period 6 and we were wondering how is it possible for the same fish to mate itself to have baby fish?